Saturday, June 7, 2014

Local Public Broadcast TV: CCSF's Accredition Situation

Local Public Broadcasting News Show Updates CCSF Situation



Did ACCJC Commission change CCSF's Fate?

SF Gate reported the full 19 person ACCJC made a change in policy on revoking accreditation at their June 6 Sacramento, CA meeting.  No specifics were revealed by the ACCJC when a copy of the policy change was requested by the California Comunity College Chancellor's Office.  It's not clear when the new policy will be made public or how it will impact CCSF.

Two days earlier CCSF Chancellor Arthur Tyler and California Community College Chancellor Brice Harris asked the same commission not to close CCSF as 95% of CCSF's problems were fixed.  If the commission agrees to extend the deadline, they would overrule their own accrediting unit's decision to disaccredit CCSF on July 31st. 


SF Public Broadcasting News Show on CCSF


(From Wiki Commons Media)

KQED Newroom, June 6, 2014 provides a quick summary of where CCSF's accreditation is and how it got here.

KQED Host Scott Schafer interviews:

  • Timothy Killikelly, California Federation of Teachers, and CCSF Political Science instructor
  • Nanette Asimov, San Francisco Chronicle education reporter
  • Rafael Mandelman, CCSF Board of Trustee member
  • Larry Kamer, CCSF Chancellor's Office spokesperson

Earlier CCSF Accreditation-related posts

Sunday, June 1, 2014

Great Teachers: The Encourager, Inspirer, and Role Model



“Years from now you won’t remember what a teacher taught but you’ll remember how they made you feel.” 

- The Rev. David Ng, Professor, Christian Education


CCSF Graduation, 2009 (Photo by Jim Wong

As I reflect on Spring 2014 graduation, I remember three college teachers who inspired me at City College of San Francisco and beyond. In 1974 I was barely an average high school graduate at CCSF with no clue for the future.  Three teachers inspired me in my journey of lifelong learning as I earned a BA in Political Science, a MA in Educational Psychology, a Masters in Divinity, and completed 75% of a MA in Political Science after CCSF!

 

Guerrilla not Gorilla

CCSF's Mr. Edward Taylor gave me my first college “A” in Political Science 1.  An elderly man, short beard, classic tweed jacket and hat, he walked me through the basics of American government and early 1970’s current events.  

Social Studies was  always my favorite school subject  and Mr. Taylor gave me an academic harbor and encouragement for my passion.  I was excited about defense and world events and he indulged me like a grandfather would their grandchild.  He let me talk in class and gently challenged me to see issues from different perspectives.  I was unpolished as a rough stone: “James, you spell insurgents types 'g-u-e-r-r-i-l-l-a'  not apes.”  How he must have chuckled at my naivete when I told him I wanted to be Secretary of Defense or State after City College.


We missed you at dinner

Mr. Henry Ingham taught me History 17B Post Civil War to the Present and thought more of my talents than I did of myself.  A friendly wiry thin man with a goatee, he taught history with care and interest.  Social science majors love history and Mr. Ingham kept me interested and talking endlessly in class.  Years later, a stranger came up and said, “Hey, weren’t you in Mr. Ingham’s history class?  Yeah, I remember you – you wouldn’t shut up.”

Mr. Ingham honored me and I disappointed him.  He was a West Point graduate and he reserved me a place at a West Point dinner event hoping I might consider his Alma mater in my future.  I was so socially awkward I was too frightened to attend.  The look of disappointment on his face in class after my no-show still stings.  Nonetheless, I earned my “A” and lifelong appreciation for his recognition of my intellectual skills long before I did.



Andy (and Me) - A Scholar's Heart

Photo by Jim Wong
 Andrew Bacevich, Professor of International Relations, Boston University, retired this spring.  Nationally renowned and respected as an expert commentator and scholar he was often seen on Bill Moyers, the PBS New Hour, a regular guest on distinguished think tank panels, and even an expert witness before Congress.  He was gracious to me an unknown student of national security issues amidst his fame as a respected Iraq war critic.  After reading his 2005 The New American Militarism: Why Americans Are Seduced by War, I was captivated by his intellect and skillful writing.  As a West Point graduate, Vietnam War veteran, distinguished scholar on American defense issues, Bacevich's criticism of the Bush Administration’s War on Terror could not be dismissed and was one of the few war critics with gravitas within the defense community.

In 2007 Bacevich lost his son a Marine Lieutenant in Iraq.  Afterwards, he wrote a heartfelt Op Ed around Mother’s Day wondering if he hadn’t done enough to criticize what he called an unnecessary war.  Afterwards, I was moved to write him offering my condolences that both he and his son did their duties as best as possible.  He was gracious to reply to me a complete stranger.

Bacevich arranges access my access to NPS, 2008
I got to meet my intellectual idol in 2008.  He graciously arranged my access to hear him speak at the Naval Post Graduate School in Montery, CA, a tightly guarded military educational facility. In the years since, I’ve gone out of my way to see him speak in the Bay Area whenever he promoted a new book.  Over time, I’ve met a Doctor, a casual acquaintance at a party, and an Iraq war vet, all knew of Bacevich’s work and it sparked long interesting conversations and friendships.  Afterwards, we called ourselves “Friends of Andy” and kept each other informed of his latest published commentary or media appearances.

Bacevich promoting Limits of Power, Capitalola Bookstore, CA, 2009

I evangelized Bacevich to all my graduate Poli Sci instructors at SF State highlighting his scholarly excellence and to anyone who liked intelligent discourse.  My hope is to write and speak as articulately and conscientiously as he does – a high and worthwhile goal to strive for.

This month, Bacevich retires from college teaching and looks to new adventures.  However, he’ll continue writing as he shared with me a possible future book on America's long misguided adventures in the Middle East.  I have no doubt his mind and spirit will continue working at his usual  high standards.

Andy and me, Capitola Bookstore, CA, 2009

My lifelong gratitude

Thank you Edward Taylor, Henry Ingham, and Andrew Bacevich for being men of letters and supporting and encouraging young and curious minds a long time ago and now.  Without you, I’d be a very different person.

Sample Bacevich Resources

Saturday, May 17, 2014

Update: ACCJC Sticking to Their Guns

Our way or the highway




The leadership of the community college accrediting body dismissed the U.S. Department’s statement affirming the authority of an accrediting body to extend deadlines for accreditation. Barbara Beno, President of the Accrediting Commission for Community and Junior Colleges (ACCJC) said the U.S. Education Department’s statement was “gibberish” and reaffirmed ACCJC's decision to take CCSF's accreditation July 2014.


ACCJC: "We're Quality Assurers"
Beno with commission Chairwoman Sherril Amador and Vice Chairman Steven Kinsella remained adamant that CCSF failed to fulfull its obligations during a meeting with SF Gate, reported Nanette Asimov, the paper's education beat writer.  The SF Gate editorial the day before supported the extension of time for CCSF to continue to correct its identified problems.  However, Beno’s subsequent words rejected the editorial's sentiments. 


Simply, Beno and the ACCJC words reaffirms their hardline attitude towards CCSF and demonstrated no interest in taking advantage of the U.S. Department of Education openness to allow ACCJC to extend deadlines.

CCSF’s fate is all but sealed in so far as ACCJC is concerned.  They are sticking to their guns come hell and high water.

One Way Out
It's clearer and clearer CCSF’s ultimate fate is wrapped up in the October 2014 court trial between the City of San Francisco vs. ACCJC.